1.0x
#Emotions#Leadership#Business Strategy#Digital Transformation#Cultural Context

How Emotions Are Made

by Lisa Feldman Barrett — 2017-03-07

Understanding the Nature of Emotions: A New Paradigm

In “How Emotions Are Made,” Lisa Feldman Barrett presents a revolutionary perspective on emotions, challenging traditional views that emotions are hardwired and universally expressed. Instead, Barrett argues that emotions are constructed experiences, shaped by individual and cultural contexts. This paradigm shift has profound implications for professionals, particularly in leadership, business strategy, and digital transformation.

The Constructed Emotion Theory

Barrett’s theory of constructed emotions posits that emotions are not innate, biologically deterministic reactions but are created by our brains using a combination of sensory input, past experiences, and cultural knowledge. This understanding encourages professionals to rethink emotional intelligence in the workplace. By recognizing that emotions are constructed, leaders can cultivate environments that promote positive emotional experiences and enhance team dynamics.

Comparison with Other Theories: Barrett’s theory contrasts with Paul Ekman’s theory of basic emotions, which suggests that emotions are universal and biologically hardwired. Ekman’s model, often used in fields like psychology and law enforcement, identifies six basic emotions. Barrett’s approach, however, aligns more closely with Richard Lazarus’s cognitive appraisal theory, which considers emotions as the result of cognitive evaluations of events.

Example: Imagine a leader in a multinational company. According to Ekman, this leader must recognize universal emotional expressions across cultures. Barrett, however, would argue that the leader should understand the unique emotional constructions of each cultural context, tailoring their approach to resonate with diverse team members.

Core Frameworks and Concepts

Barrett introduces several core frameworks that are essential for understanding the constructed nature of emotions:

1. Interoception

Interoception refers to the brain’s ability to interpret internal bodily signals. Barrett emphasizes that these signals are crucial in shaping our emotional experiences. For instance, a racing heart might be interpreted as excitement or anxiety depending on the context and past experiences.

2. Prediction

The brain constantly predicts sensory inputs based on past experiences to construct emotions. This predictive nature of the brain aids in efficiently processing information but can also lead to emotional biases if predictions are inaccurate or based on incomplete information.

3. Concepts

Concepts are mental constructs that help us categorize experiences. They are shaped by cultural and personal experiences and play a crucial role in how we interpret emotions. For example, the concept of ‘love’ varies significantly across cultures, influencing how it is felt and expressed.

4. Social Reality

Social reality is the shared understanding within a culture that influences emotional experiences. Barrett notes that emotions like pride or shame are often deeply rooted in social constructs and expectations.

5. Emotional Granularity

Emotional granularity refers to the ability to differentiate between nuanced emotional states. High granularity can lead to better emotional regulation and decision-making, as it allows for more precise identification and understanding of one’s emotional state.

Example and Application: Consider a digital marketing strategist working on a global campaign. By understanding these frameworks, the strategist can tailor messages that resonate emotionally across diverse audiences, considering cultural concepts and social realities that influence how emotions are constructed in different regions.

Key Themes

1. Implications for Leadership and Emotional Intelligence

Traditional leadership models often emphasize controlling or managing emotions. However, Barrett’s insights suggest that effective leaders should focus on understanding the construction of emotions and leveraging this knowledge to foster empathy and resilience. By acknowledging the variability and context-dependence of emotions, leaders can better navigate complex interpersonal dynamics and build more cohesive teams.

Comparison: Daniel Goleman’s Emotional Intelligence framework highlights self-awareness and self-regulation, which align with Barrett’s emphasis on understanding the constructed nature of emotions. However, Barrett offers a more nuanced view by considering the cultural and contextual construction of emotional experiences.

2. Emotions and Decision-Making in Business Strategy

Barrett’s work highlights the critical role emotions play in decision-making. Emotions are not just reactions but integral components of cognitive processes that influence strategic thinking and problem-solving. In the context of business strategy, understanding the constructed nature of emotions can help leaders make more informed decisions by considering how emotional experiences shape perceptions and judgments.

Example: A CEO deciding on a merger might feel anxious. Barrett’s theory suggests examining the cultural and historical context of this anxiety, potentially revealing deeper insights into the decision’s implications.

3. The Role of Culture and Context in Emotional Experiences

Barrett emphasizes the importance of cultural and contextual factors in shaping emotions. This perspective is particularly relevant in today’s globalized business environment, where cross-cultural interactions are common. Professionals must be attuned to cultural differences in emotional expression and interpretation to effectively manage diverse teams and engage with international clients.

Analogies and Comparisons: Consider Geert Hofstede’s cultural dimensions theory, which provides a framework for understanding cultural differences. Barrett’s emphasis on cultural context complements this by focusing on how these cultural dimensions shape emotional experiences and expressions.

4. Applying Constructed Emotion Theory to Digital Transformation

In the digital age, where technology and human interaction increasingly intersect, Barrett’s insights offer valuable guidance for digital transformation initiatives. By recognizing that emotions are constructed, organizations can design digital tools and platforms that enhance user experiences and foster positive emotional engagement. This approach aligns with principles of user-centered design and can lead to more successful technology adoption and innovation.

Case Study: A tech company developing a new app can use Barrett’s insights to create features that adapt to users’ emotional states, enhancing satisfaction and engagement.

5. Integrating Emotional Insights with Other Business Frameworks

Barrett’s theory can be integrated with other notable business frameworks, such as agile methodologies. By combining these insights, professionals can develop more holistic strategies that account for both emotional and cognitive dimensions of human behavior. This integration can lead to more adaptive, responsive organizations capable of thriving in dynamic environments.

Example: In an agile team, recognizing the constructed nature of emotions can facilitate better communication and collaboration, as team members learn to articulate and interpret emotions within the project’s context.

Final Reflection: Embracing Emotional Complexity for Professional Growth

“How Emotions Are Made” offers a transformative perspective on emotions that challenges conventional wisdom and opens new avenues for professional development. By embracing the complexity and constructed nature of emotions, leaders and organizations can foster more empathetic, innovative, and resilient cultures. This shift not only enhances individual and organizational performance but also prepares professionals to navigate the challenges of an increasingly interconnected and emotionally complex world.

Synthesis Across Domains: The implications of Barrett’s theory extend beyond psychology into leadership, design, and change management. In leadership, understanding constructed emotions can enhance team dynamics and decision-making. In design, it supports the creation of more intuitive and emotionally resonant products. In change management, recognizing emotional construction can facilitate smoother transitions by addressing the emotional underpinnings of resistance and adaptation.

Closing Perspective: As professionals, embracing the notion that emotions are not merely reactions but constructed experiences opens up opportunities for more tailored and effective communication, innovation, and strategic thinking. This perspective encourages us to see emotions not as obstacles but as integral components of human interaction and decision-making, enabling more nuanced and sophisticated approaches to personal and organizational growth.

More by Lisa Feldman Barrett

Related Videos

These videos are created by third parties and are not affiliated with or endorsed by Distilled.pro We are not responsible for their content.

  • How to Understand Emotions | Dr. Lisa Feldman Barrett

  • You aren't at the mercy of your emotions -- your brain creates them | Lisa Feldman Barrett

Further Reading